Judge Vacates Plea Deal in Hathaway Case

Photo courtesy of - Northwest Arkansas Democrat-Gazette

A plea agreement in the case of State v. Robert Hathaway has been overturned due to a procedural error. On November 9, Judge Gary Arnold vacated a plea statement that had been signed just five days prior.

The legal conflict arose because Judge Andrew Bailey, who signed the agreement on November 4, had previously recused himself from the case in October. Following that recusal, the Arkansas Supreme Court appointed Judge Gary Arnold as the assigned judge to oversee the matter.

According to Arkansas Supreme Court Administrative Order No. 16, once a judge has recused themselves, they are prohibited from taking any further action in the case, other than directing the parties to contact the clerk's office. Because signing a plea deal is an official judicial action, it fell outside the scope of Judge Bailey's authority, rendering the agreement invalid.

When asked to clarify the situation, Prosecuting Attorney David Ethredge stated that Judge Bailey's signature was a simple, unintentional mistake.

The charges against Hathaway stem from his time as a county judge. Investigations revealed that Hathaway failed to properly report the misuse of county funds by a staff member, Daniel Bolen. It was discovered that Bolen used county credit cards for personal purchases, though he did reimburse the county for some of the expenses.

Hathaway admitted that he spoke with Bolen approximately 15 times regarding the unauthorized spending throughout Bolen's employment. However, Hathaway never officially reported the misconduct to the appropriate authorities, leading to the current legal proceedings.



Share this article...

Harrison Weather

Community Partner

Newsletter

Copyright ©
North Arkansas Performing Artists Coalition (NAPAC) / The Harrison Post